Own a Piece of History – Charming 1881 Colonial-Style Home with In-Law Suite, Lake Access & No HOA
Originally built in 1881, this inviting Colonial-style property offers a rare blend of historic character and modern functionality. The 4-bedroom, 3-bathroom main home, updated in 2006, features comfortable living spaces and timeless details throughout, including beautiful hardwood floors.
The kitchen is designed for both everyday living and entertaining, featuring stainless steel appliances, a double oven, an oversized island, and a cozy breakfast nook.
Enjoy the charm of both a welcoming front porch and an expansive wraparound porch, offering plenty of space to sit, relax, and take in the surrounding scenery—perfect for morning coffee or unwinding in the evenings.
The home features a fireplace in the living room as well as a fireplace in the main-floor primary suite, adding warmth and character. The primary suite is conveniently located on the main floor. A standout historic feature is the original banister from 1881, showcasing craftsmanship and charm that is hard to find.
Additional flexible space includes a bonus room with French doors, ideal for a home office, workout room, or flex space.
The property includes access to Lake Nettie, enhancing the peaceful, natural setting, and is conveniently located just minutes from downtown Eustis and Mount Dora, with easy access to the 429 for commuting.
A valuable addition is the detached 2-bedroom, 2-bath mother-in-law suite offering approximately 1,056 sq ft of living space, complete with a living room, kitchen, and bathroom on the main level, and two bedrooms and a full bathroom upstairs. The suite also includes washer and dryer hookups and is connected to a two-car garage, offering excellent income-producing potential or space for extended family and guests.
Recent updates include:
• HVAC system replaced in 2025
• New backyard shed for additional storage.
With NO HOA, this property offers the freedom to enjoy your space while taking advantage of its unique features, charm, and versatility.
Do not miss this opportunity to own a piece of Florida history.
FREE 1-0 Temporary Buydown Rate through the seller’s preferred lender.  This is a lender-paid rate buydown that reduces the buyer’s interest rate and monthly payment through the end June.
Originally built in 1881, this inviting Colonial-style property offers a rare blend of historic character and modern functionality. The 4-bedroom, 3-bathroom main home, updated in 2006, features comfortable living spaces and timeless details throughout, including beautiful hardwood floors.
The kitchen is designed for both everyday living and entertaining, featuring stainless steel appliances, a double oven, an oversized island, and a cozy breakfast nook.
Enjoy the charm of both a welcoming front porch and an expansive wraparound porch, offering plenty of space to sit, relax, and take in the surrounding scenery—perfect for morning coffee or unwinding in the evenings.
The home features a fireplace in the living room as well as a fireplace in the main-floor primary suite, adding warmth and character. The primary suite is conveniently located on the main floor. A standout historic feature is the original banister from 1881, showcasing craftsmanship and charm that is hard to find.
Additional flexible space includes a bonus room with French doors, ideal for a home office, workout room, or flex space.
The property includes access to Lake Nettie, enhancing the peaceful, natural setting, and is conveniently located just minutes from downtown Eustis and Mount Dora, with easy access to the 429 for commuting.
A valuable addition is the detached 2-bedroom, 2-bath mother-in-law suite offering approximately 1,056 sq ft of living space, complete with a living room, kitchen, and bathroom on the main level, and two bedrooms and a full bathroom upstairs. The suite also includes washer and dryer hookups and is connected to a two-car garage, offering excellent income-producing potential or space for extended family and guests.
Recent updates include:
• HVAC system replaced in 2025
• New backyard shed for additional storage.
With NO HOA, this property offers the freedom to enjoy your space while taking advantage of its unique features, charm, and versatility.
Do not miss this opportunity to own a piece of Florida history.
FREE 1-0 Temporary Buydown Rate through the seller’s preferred lender.  This is a lender-paid rate buydown that reduces the buyer’s interest rate and monthly payment through the end June.
Property Details
Price:
$560,000
MLS #:
G5110227
Status:
Active
Beds:
4
Baths:
3
Type:
Single Family
Subtype:
Single Family Residence
Subdivision:
SUNDANCE HILLS SUB
Neighborhood:
32726eustis
Listed Date:
Apr 5, 2026
Finished Sq Ft:
2,520
Total Sq Ft:
3,141
Lot Size:
28,506 sqft / 0.65 acres (approx)
Year Built:
1881
See this Listing
Schools
Elementary School:
Eustis Elem
Middle School:
Eustis Middle
High School:
Eustis High School
Interior
Appliances
Built-In Oven, Cooktop, Dishwasher, Dryer, Microwave, Refrigerator, Solar Hot Water, Washer
Bathrooms
3 Full Bathrooms
Cooling
Central Air
Flooring
Tile, Hardwood
Heating
Central
Interior Features
Crown Molding, High Ceilings, Primary Bedroom Main Floor, Thermostat, Walk-In Closet(s)
Laundry Features
Laundry Room
Levels
Two
Exterior
Architectural Style
Colonial
Construction Materials
Metal Frame, Wood Frame
Covered Spaces
2
Direction Faces
Northwest
Exterior Features
French Doors, Irrigation System, Private Mailbox, Private Yard
Fencing
Vinyl
Garage Spaces
2
Lot Features
City Lot, Landscaped
Other Structures
Shed(s)
Patio And Porch Features
Front Porch, Rear Porch, Wrap Around
Roof
Shingle
Security Features
Smoke Detector(s)
View
Water
Window Features
Window Treatments
Financial
Tax Year
2025
Taxes
$5,775
Map
Community
- Address835 BUTCH CASSIDY LANE EUSTIS FL
- SubdivisionSUNDANCE HILLS SUB
- CityEUSTIS
- CountyLake
- Zip Code32726
Subdivisions in EUSTIS
- 0002
- 00E1 EUSTIS
- 44 GABLES PH 02A
- 44 GABLES PH 03
- ABRAMS RIDGE
- ACREAGE
- ACREAGE & UNREC
- BADGERS DIV
- BLACK BEAR RESERVE
- BLUE LAKE ESTATES
- BREEZEE SHORES PT REP
- BRIARCLIFF
- BRIGHTWATER PLACE PH 02
- BROADVUE HEIGHTS
- BROOKSHIRE SUB
- CENTURY OAKS ESTATES
- CHERRYTREE/WASHINGTON
- CLEAR LAKE ESTATES
- CONNORS COVE
- COURTNEY JANE ESTATES SUB
- CRICKET LAKE VILLAGE 5TH ADD
- CROOKED LAKE TERRACE
- CROOKED LAKE TERRACE SUB
- DEER PARK SUB
- DIEDRICHS ADD/EUSTIS
- DRUID PARK SUB
- EICHELBERGER ESTATES 1
- EICHELBERGER ESTATES 2
- EL BONITO
- EL CERITO
- ELDORADO HEIGHTS
- ELDORADO HEIGHTS EATON SUB
- ESTATES AT BLACK BEAR
- ESTATES AT BLACK BEAR RESERVE
- ESTES RESERVE
- EUSTIS
- EUSTIS 44 GABLES
- EUSTIS ABRAMS RIDGE
- EUSTIS ARBOR HILLS UNIT 02
- EUSTIS BADGER
- EUSTIS BAY STATE SOUTH PH 01
- EUSTIS BAY STATE SOUTH PH 02
- EUSTIS BELMONT HEIGHTS
- EUSTIS BISHOPS SUB
- EUSTIS BRIGHTWATER PLACE
- EUSTIS CLIFFORD PARK
- EUSTIS COLLEGE HEIGHTS
- EUSTIS COUNTRY CLUB MANOR MHP
- EUSTIS COUNTRY CLUB MANOR MHP UNIT 02A
- EUSTIS COUNTRY CLUB MANOR MOBILE HM P
- EUSTIS CRICKET LAKE VILLAGE
- EUSTIS CRICKET LAKE VILLAGE SUB
- EUSTIS CROOKED LAKE RIDGE ADD 01
- EUSTIS DIXIE HWY SUB
- EUSTIS DRUID PARK
- EUSTIS GOLFVIEW ESTATES
- EUSTIS GRAND ISLAND SHORES ADD 02
- EUSTIS HANNUM HEIGHTS
- EUSTIS HARBOR ISLAND VILLAS
- EUSTIS HAZZARD’S HOMESTEAD
- EUSTIS HAZZARDS HOMESTEAD
- EUSTIS HEATH TERRACE
- EUSTIS HERMOSA SHORES
- EUSTIS HIGHLAND PARK
- EUSTIS HOGAN TERRACE
- EUSTIS HOGANS SUB
- EUSTIS HOMEWOOD
- EUSTIS IDLEWILD HEIGHTS
- EUSTIS JENSON PARK
- EUSTIS KING HOMESTEAD
- EUSTIS KNOLLWOOD VILLAGE
- EUSTIS LAKE EUSTIS PLACE
- EUSTIS LAKE JOANNA HEIGHTS
- EUSTIS LAKE NETTIE COURT
- EUSTIS LAKE SAUNDERS SUB
- EUSTIS LAKEVIEW COURT
- EUSTIS LAKEVIEW HEIGHTS
- EUSTIS LAKEVIEW PARK
- EUSTIS LAKEVIEW PLACE
- EUSTIS MC CLELLANDS
- EUSTIS MISTY OAKS
- EUSTIS NORTHSHORE
- EUSTIS OCKLAWAHA SUB
- EUSTIS ORCHID LAKE
- EUSTIS OWENS & GEISLER REV
- EUSTIS PINE MEADOWS FAIRWAY ESTATES
- EUSTIS PINECREST
- EUSTIS PINEHURST
- EUSTIS PROMONTORY COVE
- EUSTIS QUAIL HOLLOW
- EUSTIS REAUME PARK
- EUSTIS REMINGTON CLUB PH 02 LT 61 ORB
- EUSTIS RIDGEVIEW AT EAST CROOKED LAKE ADD 01
- EUSTIS RIDGEVIEW AT EAST CROOKED LAKE ADD 02
- EUSTIS ROSENWALD GARDENS
- EUSTIS RUSTWOOD
- EUSTIS SHOREACRES 03
- EUSTIS TAYLORS SUB
- EUSTIS TOWNHILL
- EUSTIS TOWNHILL SUB
- EUSTIS TROPICAL SHORE
- EUSTIS UBEGUILDA HEIGHTS
- EUSTIS WEAVERS SUB
- EUSTIS WESTGATE PH 02 LT 41
- EUSTIS WESTGATE SUB
- EUSTIS WILLOW CREST SUB
- EUSTIS WINCHESTER ESTATES TR A & B
- EUSTIS, HAZZARD’S HOMESTEAD
- FAIROAKS CONDO
- FARMSTEAD 44
- FLORIDA HILL SUB
- FOREST LAKES AND HILLS
- FOREST PARK
- FRST LAKES & HILLS ADD 02
- GRAND ISLAND SHORES ADD 01
- GREENBRIAR SUB
- JOANNA SHORES
- LAKE LINCOLN SUB
- LAKE LOUISE TERRACE
- LAKE NETTIE TERRACE
- LAKE SWATARA RESERVE
- LAKE WOODWARD COVE
- LAKEWOOD RANCHES
- LAKEWOOD RANCHES SUB
- LYNNHURST
- MAGNOLIA FARMS
- MAP/PLAT THEREOF
- MAYHILL
- METES AND BOUNDS
- MICHIGAN ACRES
- MILKY WAY ADD NO 1
- MISTY OAKS
- MRS S D SHORTS SUB
- NA-UNINCORPORATED
- OAKS AT SUMMER GLEN
- OFFICIAL MAP/EUSTIS
- OFFICIAL MAP/TOWN/EUSTIS
- ORANGE SUMMIT
- ORLANDO HILLS
- PARK PLACE ON LAKE JOANNA
- PARK PLACE ON LAKE JOANNA 3RD ADDITION
- PARK PLACE ON LAKE JOANNA ADD 01
- PARK PLACE ON LAKE JOANNA ADD 02
- PINE HILLS
- PINE LAKES
- PINE LAKES SOUTH
- PINE MEADOWS 40’S
- PINE MEADOWS 50’S
- PINE MEADOWS RESERVE PHASE 1A
- PINE PARK FIRST ADD
- RAINBOW RIDGE
- REHRERS SUB
- REICH RESERVE
- RICHARDS ADD
- ROSENWALD GARDENS
- ROSENWALD GARDENS PT REP SUB
- ROYAL TRAILS
- ROYAL TRAILS UNIT #1
- ROYAL TRAILS UNIT 01
- SORRENTO SHORES
- SPRING RIDGE ESTATES
- SUNDANCE HILLS SUB
- TALLAHASSEE MERIDIAN
- TRIANGLE SUB
- UNINCORPORATED
- UPSON DOWNS
- VILLAGE AT BLACK BEAR UNIT 02 LT 94 PB 51
- WANDERING PONDS SUB
- YALE RETREAT ADD
Market Summary
Current real estate data for Single Family in EUSTIS as of Sep 16, 2026
238
Single Family Listed
94
Avg DOM
229
Avg $ / SqFt
$529,738
Avg List Price
Property Summary
- Located in the SUNDANCE HILLS SUB subdivision, 835 BUTCH CASSIDY LANE EUSTIS FL is a Single Family for sale in EUSTIS, FL, 32726. It is listed for $560,000 and features 4 beds, 3 baths, and has approximately 2,520 square feet of living space, and was originally constructed in 1881. The current price per square foot is $222. The average price per square foot for Single Family listings in EUSTIS is $229. The average listing price for Single Family in EUSTIS is $529,738. To schedule a showing of MLS#g5110227 at 835 BUTCH CASSIDY LANE in EUSTIS, FL, contact your WINDERMERE INTERNATIONAL REALTY agent at 4079901329.
Similar Listings Nearby
Courtesy of WILLOW FISHER REAL ESTATE. Disclaimer: All data relating to real estate for sale on this page comes from the Broker Reciprocity (BR) of the Orlando/Tampa – FL. Detailed information about real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than WINDERMERE INTERNATIONAL REALTY include the name of the listing broker. Neither the listing company nor WINDERMERE INTERNATIONAL REALTY shall be responsible for any typographical errors, misinformation, misprints and shall be held totally harmless. The Broker providing this data believes it to be correct, but advises interested parties to confirm any item before relying on it in a purchase decision. Copyright 2026. Orlando/Tampa – FL. All rights reserved. 835 BUTCH CASSIDY LANE
EUSTIS, FL
