Take your pick! The seller is offering an interest rate buydown with rates as low as 5.5% on a 7-year ARM for qualified buyers, OR a 2025 Godfrey Sweetwater 18′ pontoon boat with a 75 HP Yamaha motor. Whether you prefer mortgage savings or making memories on the water, the choice is yours! Set behind the gates of Windermere Club, this lakefront residence delivers everyday comfort with a resort-style backdrop on beautiful Lake Crescent. Offering 4 bedrooms and 3 baths, the home is designed for easy living and effortless entertaining, with bright, open gathering spaces that keep the water views front and center. At the heart of the home, the kitchen pairs generous prep space with a welcoming bar and an adjacent dining area that comfortably seats six, while a separate formal dining room adds flexibility for holidays and special occasions. The main living area is wrapped in expansive windows, filling the home with natural light and framing tranquil lake scenery throughout the day. Step outside to a covered lanai and screened pool area ideal for quiet mornings, sunset dinners, and everything in between. Take a dip in the saltwater pool, now enhanced with a new pool heater and an Aqua Link pool & spa control system for simple, modern management. The primary suite is a private retreat with captivating lake views and a spa-like bath featuring large windows overlooking a secluded courtyard. Three additional bedrooms provide plenty of space for family, guests, or a home office setup. For true lakefront living, enjoy the newer dock with a covered boat lift, perfect for skiing, cruising, kayaking, or paddle boarding whenever the mood strikes. Upgrades and highlights include double pane windows and sliding glass doors, Shark Coating garage floors, a water purifier, Paradise Grill outdoor kitchen with cover and TV, new pool heater, two brand new AC units, a new water heater, plus additional notable improvements throughout. This is the Windermere waterfront lifestyle, refined, relaxed, and ready to enjoy. Be sure to click on the virtual tour links.
Property Details
Price:
$1,725,000
MLS #:
O6413242
Status:
Active
Beds:
4
Baths:
3
Type:
Single Family
Subtype:
Single Family Residence
Subdivision:
BUTLER BAY
Neighborhood:
34786windermere
Listed Date:
Jun 3, 2026
Finished Sq Ft:
3,297
Total Sq Ft:
4,058
Lot Size:
23,191 sqft / 0.53 acres (approx)
Year Built:
1990
See this Listing
Schools
Elementary School:
Windermere Elem
Middle School:
Bridgewater Middle
High School:
Windermere High School
Interior
Appliances
Built-In Oven, Convection Oven, Cooktop, Dishwasher, Disposal, Dryer, Exhaust Fan, Microwave, Range Hood, Refrigerator, Solar Hot Water Owned, Touchless Faucet, Washer, Water Filtration System, Water Purifier, Water Softener
Bathrooms
3 Full Bathrooms
Cooling
Central Air
Flooring
Brick/Stone, Carpet, Travertine, Hardwood
Heating
Central, Electric
Interior Features
Ceiling Fan(s), Eating Space In Kitchen, High Ceilings, Open Floorplan, Primary Bedroom Main Floor, Split Bedroom, Stone Counters, Thermostat, Walk-In Closet(s)
Laundry Features
Inside, Laundry Room
Levels
Two
Exterior
Architectural Style
Custom, Mediterranean
Association Amenities
Gated
Attached Garage YN
1
Community Features
Water Access, Gated Community – No Guard
Construction Materials
Stucco, Wood Frame
Covered Spaces
2
Direction Faces
Northwest
Exterior Features
Irrigation System, Private Mailbox, Rain Gutters, Sliding Doors
Garage Spaces
2
Lot Features
In County, Sidewalk
Open Parking YN
1
Parking Features
Circular Driveway, Electric Vehicle Charging Station(s), Garage Door Opener, Garage Faces Side, Oversized
Patio And Porch Features
Covered
Roof
Tile
Security Features
Smoke Detector(s)
Spa Features
Heated, In Ground
View
Water
Waterfront Features
Lake Front
Window Features
Double Pane Windows, ENERGY STAR Qualified Windows, Shutters
Financial
HOA Fee
$2,385
HOA Fee Frequency
Annually
HOA Includes
Private Road
HOA Name
Terri Grace/Sentry Management
HOA Phone
407-788-6700
Tax Year
2025
Taxes
$16,376
Map
Community
- Address2503 BUTLER BAY DRIVE N WINDERMERE FL
- SubdivisionBUTLER BAY
- CityWINDERMERE
- CountyOrange
- Zip Code34786
Subdivisions in WINDERMERE
- ALADAR ON LAKE BUTLER
- ASHLIN PARK
- ASHLIN PARK PH 2
- BALMORAL
- BELLARIA
- BELMERE VILLAGE
- BELMERE VILLAGE G-5
- BELMERE VILLAGE G2 48 65
- BUTLER BAY
- BUTLER BAY,WINDERMERE CLUB
- BUTLER RIDGE
- CARRINGTON
- CARRINGTON 80/53 TRACT B
- CASA DEL LAGO
- CASA DEL LAGO REP
- CASA DEL LAGO-REPLAT
- CASABELLA
- CASABELLA PH 2
- CHAINE DU LAC
- DAVIS SHORES
- DOWN ACRES ESTATES
- DOWN POINT SUB
- EDEN ISLE
- EDEN ISLE BOAT RAMP
- EDENS HAMMOCK
- ENCLAVE
- ENCLAVE/BERKSHIRE PARK B G H I
- ESTANCIA/WINDERMERE
- ESTATES AT LAKE CLARICE
- ESTATES AT WINDERMERE
- FARMS
- GARDENS/ISLEWORTH UN #2
- GLENMUIR
- GLENMUIR 48 39
- GLENMUIR UT 02 51 42
- GOTHA TOWN
- ISLES WINDERMERE
- ISLEWORTH
- ISLEWORTH WEST
- KEENE’S POINTE
- KEENES POINT
- KEENES POINTE
- KEENES POINTE 46/104
- KEENES POINTE UNIT 03 46/104
- LAKE BURDEN SOUTH PH 2
- LAKE BURDEN SOUTH PH I
- LAKE BUTLER ESTATES
- LAKE BUYNAK ESTATES
- LAKE CAWOOD COVE
- LAKE CAWOOD ESTATES
- LAKE CAWOOD ESTS REP
- LAKE CRESCENT RESERVE
- LAKE CYPRESS COVE PH 03
- LAKE DAVIS RESERVE A & B
- LAKE DOWN COVE
- LAKE DOWN ESTATES
- LAKE DOWN POINTE 50 42
- LAKE DOWN SHORES
- LAKE DOWN SHORES REP
- LAKE HANCOCK SHORES
- LAKE OLIVIA RESERVE
- LAKE SAWYER
- LAKE SAWYER SOUTH
- LAKE SAWYER SOUTH PH 01
- LAKE SAWYER SOUTH PH 03
- LAKE SAWYER SOUTH PH 05
- LAKE SAWYER SOUTH PH 1
- LAKE SAWYER SOUTH PH 2
- LAKE SAWYER SOUTH PH 3
- LAKE SAWYER SOUTH PH 5
- LAKES OF WINDERMERE LAKE REAMS TOWNHOMES PHASE 3
- LAKES OF WINDERMERE PEACHTREE
- LAKES OF WINDERMERE PH 2A
- LAKES WINDERMERE PH 01 49 108
- LAKES/WINDERMERE LAKE REAMS TWNH
- LAKES/WINDERMERE PH 02A
- LAKES/WINDERMERE PH 03 P & Q
- LAKES/WINDERMERE-LK REAMS TWHM
- LAKES/WINDERMERE-LK REAMS TWNH
- LAKES/WINDERMERE-PEACHTREE
- LAKESIDE AT LAKES OF WINDERMERE
- LAKESIDE AT LAKES OF WINDERMERE CONDOMINIUM
- LAKESIDE VILLAS
- LAKESIDE/LKS
- LAKESIDE/LKS/WINDERMERE
- LEGADO
- LEGADO 95/47 LOT 100
- LEGADO 95/47 LOT 99
- MANORS AT BUTLER BAY PH 01
- MANORS AT BUTLER BAY PH 02
- MARINA BAY ESTATES
- MARSH SUB
- MERRICK LNDG
- METCALF PARK REP
- OASIS COVE I/LAKESIDE VILLAGE PH 01
- OASIS COVE II/LAKESIDE VILLAGE PH
- OASIS COVE/LAKESIDE VILLAGE PH VII
- OXFORD MOOR 47/30
- PALMS AT WINDERMERE
- PALMS/WINDERMERE
- PEACHTREE PARK
- PRESTON SQUARE
- PROVIDENCE PH 01 50 03
- PROVIDENCE PH 02
- RESERVE AT BELMERE
- RESERVE AT BELMERE PH 02 48 144
- RESERVE AT LAKE BUTLER SOUND
- RESERVE AT WINDERMERE
- ROBERTS LANDING
- ROYAL ESTATES
- SADDLECREST AT WINDERMERE
- SANCTUARY AT LAKES OF WINDERMERE
- SANDY SHORES
- SILVER WOODS
- SILVER WOODS PH 01
- SILVER WOODS PH 02
- SILVER WOODS PH 03
- SILVER WOODS PH 04
- SILVER WOODS PH 05
- SOUTHBRIDGE VILLAGE
- STILLWATER XINGS PRCL SC-13 PH
- SUMMERPORT
- SUMMERPORT EDENS HAMMOCK
- SUMMERPORT PH 03
- SUMMERPORT PH 04 C E F & G
- SUMMERPORT PH 05
- SUMMERPORT PH 2
- SUMMERPORT PH 5
- SUMMERPORT PHASE 1
- SUMMERPORT PHASE4
- SUMMERPORT TRAIL PH 2
- SUMMERPORT TRL
- SUNSET BAY
- TENNYSON PK/SUMMERPORT
- VINEYARDS OF HORIZONS WEST PHASE 1B
- VINEYARDS/HORIZONS WEST PH 2B
- VINEYARDS/HORIZONS WEST PH 4
- WATERFORD POINTE PH 02 REP
- WATERFORD POINTE PH 1 RESERVE
- WATERSTONE
- WATERSTONE A D E F G H J L
- WAUSEON RIDGE
- WEATHERSTONE ON LAKE OLIVIA
- WEST POINT COMMONS
- WESTOVER CLUB PH 01 44/139
- WESTSIDE VILLAGE
- WHICKHAM PARK
- WHITNEY ISLES/BELMERE PH 02
- WICKHAM PARK
- WICKHAM PARK 04 05 06 09 10 11 12 01
- WILLOWS AT LAKE RHEA
- WILLOWS AT LAKE RHEA PH 01
- WILLOWS AT LAKE RHEA PH 03
- WINDERMERE
- WINDERMERE DOWNS
- WINDERMERE ISLE
- WINDERMERE ISLE PH 2
- WINDERMERE ISLE-PH 2
- WINDERMERE LNDGS FD-1
- WINDERMERE LNDGS PH 02
- WINDERMERE SOUND
- WINDERMERE SOUND PH 2
- WINDERMERE TERRACE
- WINDERMERE TOWN
- WINDERMERE TOWN REP
- WINDERMERE TRAILS
- WINDERMERE TRAILS PARCEL 3 83/125 LOT 58
- WINDERMERE TRAILS PHASE 1C
- WINDERMERE TRLS
- WINDERMERE TRLS PH 1C
- WINDERMERE TRLS PH 3A
- WINDERMERE TRLS PH 3B
- WINDERMERE TRLS PH 4B
- WINDERMERE TRLS PH 5A
- WINDERMERE TRLS PH 5B
- WINDERMERE TRLS PRCL 3
- WINDSOR HILL
- WINDSTONE
Market Summary
Current real estate data for Single Family in WINDERMERE as of Oct 27, 2026
238
Single Family Listed
121
Avg DOM
493
Avg $ / SqFt
$2,625,453
Avg List Price
Property Summary
- Located in the BUTLER BAY subdivision, 2503 BUTLER BAY DRIVE N WINDERMERE FL is a Single Family for sale in WINDERMERE, FL, 34786. It is listed for $1,725,000 and features 4 beds, 3 baths, and has approximately 3,297 square feet of living space, and was originally constructed in 1990. The current price per square foot is $523. The average price per square foot for Single Family listings in WINDERMERE is $493. The average listing price for Single Family in WINDERMERE is $2,625,453. To schedule a showing of MLS#o6413242 at 2503 BUTLER BAY DRIVE N in WINDERMERE, FL, contact your WINDERMERE INTERNATIONAL REALTY agent at 4079901329.
Similar Listings Nearby
Courtesy of THE SIMON SIMAAN GROUP. Disclaimer: All data relating to real estate for sale on this page comes from the Broker Reciprocity (BR) of the Orlando/Tampa – FL. Detailed information about real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than WINDERMERE INTERNATIONAL REALTY include the name of the listing broker. Neither the listing company nor WINDERMERE INTERNATIONAL REALTY shall be responsible for any typographical errors, misinformation, misprints and shall be held totally harmless. The Broker providing this data believes it to be correct, but advises interested parties to confirm any item before relying on it in a purchase decision. Copyright 2026. Orlando/Tampa – FL. All rights reserved. 2503 BUTLER BAY DRIVE N
WINDERMERE, FL
